The Screen Scribe

There are few things trickier in television than following up a cultural phenomenon. Wednesday’s first season was lightning in a bottle, combining gothic flair with teen mystery and a breakout performance from Jenna Ortega that launched a thousand TikTok dances. Now the question looms large: could lightning strike twice? The answer, unfortunately, is complicated.

Season two finds Wednesday Addams returning to Nevermore Academy after the chaos of the first year. The promise of a fresh start is short lived, however, as a new wave of mysteries creeps into the halls of the academy and beyond. Strange disappearances, cryptic messages, and whispers of a deeper conspiracy challenge Wednesday as she is forced once again into the role of reluctant detective. Familiar faces return while new characters enter the fold, each with secrets of their own. It is a story that attempts to expand the scope of Nevermore while still clinging to the intimate character beats that made the original season resonate.

The problems become clear almost immediately. Where the first season was a tight gothic mystery with a singular focus, season two sprawls. Multiple plot threads fight for attention, leaving the central mystery muddled and often confusing. Episodes linger too long on side stories that lack payoff, draining momentum from the overall narrative. The writing is at times heavy handed, forcing emotional beats rather than allowing them to unfold naturally. At times, the writing mistakes morbid wit for snarky one-liners, which is a little like confusing a guillotine with a butter knife. Worst of all, several returning characters feel like shadows of their former selves, their motivations reduced or rewritten in ways that clash with the groundwork already laid.

Jenna Ortega herself remains a force, but even her performance is occasionally undermined by dialogue that strains under the weight of its own cleverness. Her sardonic wit still sparks, yet some of her best moments are buried beneath subplots that never justify their presence. Other characters suffer more. Enid, once a lively foil to Wednesday’s deadpan, spends much of the season directionless. Bianca’s arc, previously rich with intrigue, is reduced to little more than background noise. Even the new antagonistic presence fails to carry the menace of last season’s foes, feeling more like a puzzle piece than a fully realised threat.

It is not all doom and gloom, however. When the season clicks, it really clicks. The visual design continues to impress, with gothic architecture, shadow-soaked corridors, and eerie landscapes framing the action beautifully. The costume work and music still craft that unmistakable Addams atmosphere. There are sequences where Wednesday’s sharp tongue and investigative mind combine in ways that remind us why this show took off in the first place. The sparring of wits between Wednesday and her peers remains enjoyable, and her growth, though uneven, offers moments of genuine depth.

The highlight once again is Ortega herself. Even weighed down by weaker writing, she commands the screen. Her performance captures the razor thin balance of detachment and vulnerability, reminding us that Wednesday’s deadpan exterior hides a simmering emotional core. Caught between her disdain for the world and her reluctant bonds with those around her, Ortega provides a grounding force even when the story threatens to drift apart.

There are also flashes of brilliance in the way season two builds upon Nevermore’s lore. The mythology is richer, hinting at deeper currents beneath the academy’s walls. Some of the new characters, though unevenly written, offer intriguing possibilities for future stories. When the show dares to lean fully into the dark whimsy of its premise, it remains a delight.

In the end, Wednesday’s second season is a mixed bag. It is larger, louder, and more ambitious than its predecessor, but in the process it sacrifices some of the tight focus and narrative clarity that made season one such a sensation. Fans will still find plenty to enjoy, from Ortega’s magnetic presence to the atmospheric visuals, but the uneven storytelling prevents the season from achieving the same spark of brilliance.

Wednesday season two is a watchable but frustrating continuation. It has moments of charm and style, yet too often stumbles under the weight of its expanded ambitions. For those already invested in the character, it remains worth the trip back to Nevermore. For newcomers, the first season still stands as the stronger, sharper introduction to the macabre world of Wednesday Addams.

3 / 5 ✨ from the Screen Scribe

(All images and videos are owned by and courtesy of Youtube)